Jesse and Cassidy have had their ups and downs — Jesse always overshadowing Cassidy as the hero, Cassidy sleeping with Tulip, the whole vampire thing. While things haven’t been perfect, Jesse never saw this coming.

Watch the WTF Moment from Episode 9

When God gets ahold of Cassidy, he knows exactly which weak spots to hit. And now that he’s lost Tulip all over again to Jesse, Cassidy’s loyalty is being put to the test. Watch as Cassidy breaks his betrayal to Jesse in this scene from the latest episode.

Plus, see the full episode available now on amc.com and the AMC app for mobile and devices.

The series finale of Preacher airs Sundays 10/9c. To get full episodes, behind-the-scenes video and more, sign up for the weekly Insiders Club.